America’s Got Talent (AGT) has long been a stage where dreams materialize and unexpected talents emerge. The 2024 season was no exception, delivering a series of jaw-dropping moments that left audiences and judges alike in awe. Here are some of the most shocking highlights from AGT 2024!
1. Simon Cowell Shocks AGT Fans with Unbelievable Golden Buzzer Hijack
During the August 20 episode of NBC’s popular series, tensions humorously escalated between Simon Cowell and Howie Mandel as they playfully argued over AIRFOOTWORKS’ remarkable dance routine and who deserved the credit for awarding them the Golden Buzzer.
The group’s captivating air dance performance to Ed Sheeran’s “Celestial” had both the judges and audience on their feet, completely enthralled. Then, the unexpected happened.
“Terry, I’m about to get myself fired!”
Simon, 64, announced to host Terry Crews before boldly pressing the Golden Buzzer — even though Howie, 68, was the only judge eligible to use it that night.
As gold confetti cascaded from above and AIRFOOTWORKS rejoiced on stage, Simon eagerly made his way over to join the celebration, while Howie dashed over, clearly overwhelmed with panic.
“Simon wants to take the credit. Howie, this was your Golden Buzzer!” Terry said, before Howie urgently clarified, “This is mine! This is mine!“
Howie then praised founder Takashi Jonishi and his group, telling them, “You guys are athletes, you guys are dancers, you guys are creators!“
In turn, Takashi excitedly said, “I dreamed all the time for this moment!“
After a commercial break, Terry informed the audience that the Golden Buzzer for the evening was initially intended for Howie, but Simon managed to take it from him.
“Look at this!” Terry exclaimed, as a slow-motion replay of the moment played on the screen.
“Simon jumps — Howie reaches it first, but Simon attempts to press the Golden Buzzer.”
Howie responded, “It’s me, right? I feel like I’ve been wronged!“
Simon replied, “Look, when you watch the footage again, you’ll see that my finger touched it just before Howie’s, so that’s how it happened.“
“Well, keep your fingers off of my buzzer!” Howie jokingly responded.
2. Phillip Lewis’s Fiery AGT Fiasco: When Batons Burned, But His Spirit Shone
America’s Got Talent contestant shocks judges with a huge mistake during live fire baton twirling performance.
After wowing the judges with his baton twirling during the auditions, Phillip returned to the AGT stage with a new, riskier routine set to Fleur East’s “Like That.“
Unfortunately, things took a turn when Phillip dropped his batons twice within the first minute of his performance.
Judge Sofia Vergara appeared concerned when the Georgia native failed to catch the baton for a third time. Determined to take the performance to the next level, Phillip ignited the batons with fire.
Thankfully, the rest of his routine went smoothly, and Sofia’s fellow judges, Simon Cowell and Heidi Klum, joined her in giving Phillip a standing ovation, while Howie Mandel remain seated.
Overall, the judges took the situation positively and did their best to encourage Phillip. For instance, 68-year-old Howie Mandel even joked, saying:
“A lot of other baton twirlers catch everything, but you’re unique – you catch 80%!”
However, home fans were less forgiving, and several social media users suggested that the judges should have used their buzzers instead of offering what some called “participation trophy energy.” One user on X wrote:
“So only the best go through. He dropped the baton. There are acts that perfected their craft. I would have buzzed Phillip as he dropped the baton several times during the performance. Sorry, but not everyone gets a trophy.”
So, whose side are you on? Do you think the judges were right to handle the situation with such leniency, offering words of encouragement to Phillip, or should they have been more pragmatic and taken a firmer approach?
3. 9-Year-Old Pranysqa Mishra’s Golden Buzzer Performance at AGT Moves Hearts
Nine-year-old Pranysqa Mishra delivered a powerful rendition of Tina Turner’s “River Deep – Mountain High,” dedicating her performance to her grandmother. Her soulful voice and emotional delivery moved judge Heidi Klum to press the Golden Buzzer, sending Pranysqa directly to the next round. The heartfelt moment was amplified when Pranysqa shared the news with her grandmother via a video call, bringing tears to many eyes in the audience.
9-year-old Pranysqa Mishra from Tampa, Florida, stepped onto the AGT stage and shared with the judges that her inspiration for singing came from her grandmother, who encouraged her to follow in the footsteps of legendary women in music such as Aretha Franklin, Whitney Houston, and Tina Turner.
“My grandma always tells me to sing my heart out and that one day I’ll be on the big stage”
Pranysqa explained, adding that she would call her grandmother if she won.
Pranysqa then stunned both the judges and the audience with her powerful voice, delivering a breathtaking rendition of Tina Turner’s “River Deep — Mountain High,” a song the iconic artist originally performed with her partner Ike Turner.
In a touching moment, Pranysqa, with Heidi Klum by her side, video-called her grandmother, who was overwhelmed with emotion upon hearing the incredible news that her granddaughter would be advancing to the next round of the competition.
While Klum was the one to press the Golden Buzzer for Pranysqa, the other judges were equally impressed. Even Simon Cowell, known for his critical nature, praised the young singer’s performance, calling it “really, really good.
4. Shocking Elimination of Bboy Samuka Sparks Fury Among Fans
The elimination of Brazilian breakdancer Bboy Samuka from America’s Got Talent has sent shockwaves through fans and viewers alike. Samuka, who wowed audiences with his stunning one-legged dance moves, was unexpectedly cut from the semifinals, leaving many feeling the decision was deeply unfair. Social media erupted with accusations that the competition was “rigged,” and fans expressed their outrage at what they saw as a blatant oversight of his incredible skill and resilience.
Bboy Samuka‘s journey on AGT was nothing short of inspiring. With only one leg, he demonstrated not just extraordinary athleticism, but also an unyielding determination that endeared him to viewers. His powerful performances not only showcased his breakdancing prowess but also delivered a compelling message of perseverance and courage. For many fans, his elimination felt like a slap in the face of his dedication and the message he represented.
Since the shocking episode aired, viewers have taken to social media in droves, calling for the show’s producers to answer for their decision. Many argued that Samuka’s performance should have earned him a spot in the finals, and they expressed their disappointment at what they viewed as a glaring oversight. His fans are now demanding greater transparency in the competition, and some are even questioning whether the results were influenced by factors other than pure talent.
One Instagram user voiced the sentiments of many, saying:
“I can’t believe Samuka is out! His performance was beyond amazing. How can they eliminate someone who inspires millions? This is so unfair.”
Bboy Samuka‘s elimination has become a rallying cry for fans who feel that America’s Got Talent has lost its way. While the show has long been a platform for showcasing extraordinary talent, incidents like this highlight the growing divide between viewers’ expectations and the reality of reality TV. Whether or not the show will address these concerns remains to be seen, but one thing is clear: the backlash surrounding Samuka‘s elimination has opened up a much-needed conversation about fairness and integrity in talent competitions.
What’s your take on Samuka’s elimination? Was the decision fair, or do you believe his incredible performance deserved a place in the finals? Share your thoughts—are you standing with Samuka in this fight for fairness, or do you think the judges made the right call?
5. From Golden Buzzer to Broken Elbow: Sebastián and Sonia’s AGT Journey Faced a Tough Test
In a stunning twist of fate, Sebastián and Sonia, the breathtaking aerial duo, faced an unexpected challenge that nearly derailed their dreams during rehearsals for America’s Got Talent (AGT). The couple, known for their gravity-defying performances, experienced an unsettling setback when Sonia fractured her elbow, throwing their preparations into turmoil.
Just days after their incredible Golden Buzzer moment from Simon Cowell, the aerialists were struck by a major blow. Sonia’s injury left them questioning their future in the competition. The injury occurred during a rehearsal, as they prepared for their next thrilling act. The moment they had worked so hard for seemed to be slipping away in the blink of an eye.
“Everything was going so well, we were finally in sync, and the crowd had just given us that energy we needed. And then—boom! A moment of carelessness, and Sonia was in pain”
Sebastián recalled, his voice tinged with concern.
Despite the gravity of the situation, Sebastián and Sonia’s resilience has always been their strength. Both determined to not let this injury define them, they faced the challenge head-on. Sonia’s doctors have advised rest, but the aerialist duo has refused to give up on their dream to dazzle AGT’s audience and judges with their iconic performance.
“We’ve worked so hard to get to this point. We’re not going to let an injury stop us from giving everything we have”
Sonia said, her spirit unshaken.
With Sonia sidelined due to a fractured elbow, the pressure was on Sebastián to step up in a way that no one expected. In a performance that was both heart-pounding and emotional, Sebastián performed an aerial act that left the audience on the edge of their seats.
Instead of the usual duo act, Sebastián soared through the air alone, showcasing his incredible strength, agility, and artistry. His performance was not just a display of skill—it was a testament to his passion and unwavering commitment to the act that he and Sonia had worked so hard to build together.
Sebastián’s solo performance wasn’t just about the athleticism and beauty of aerial arts—it was also an emotional tribute to Sonia. The connection between the two was felt in every twist, turn, and leap. Despite performing without his partner, Sebastián made it clear that this performance was a nod to the partnership that had made them AGT sensations.
“It’s not just about me. This is for Sonia, for all we’ve been through together. She’s here in spirit, and I can feel her strength with me.”
Sebastián said after the performance.
The Golden Buzzer was not just a recognition of Sebastián’s incredible talent, but also an acknowledgment of his courage and unwavering dedication to his craft.
“You’ve shown us more than just your incredible skills. You’ve shown us what it means to be a true performer, to fight through adversity and pour your heart into your work. This act is unforgettable.”
Simon said. The Golden Buzzer was more than a prize—it was a clear sign that Sebastián’s solo act had captivated not only the fans but also the very judges who hold the power to take contestants all the way to the final. With that press, the duo was granted a pass to the America’s Got Talent finale, despite Sonia’s injury.
Sebastián’s solo performance will go down as one of the most memorable moments in America’s Got Talent history. It’s a powerful reminder of the resilience it takes to chase a dream, especially when facing unexpected hurdles. And for Sebastián and Sonia, this is just the beginning—no injury or setback can break the bond they share or the passion that drives them forward.
Conclusion: A Year of Unforgettable Surprises on AGT
The 2024 season of America’s Got Talent was nothing short of electrifying. From Simon Cowell’s bold Golden Buzzer move to young prodigies breaking barriers, each episode brought its own unforgettable moments that left audiences on the edge of their seats. The year wasn’t just about the acts—it was about the emotions, the drama, and the sheer unpredictability that AGT delivers year after year.
As we look back on the highs and lows of the season, it’s clear that America’s Got Talent continues to push the limits of what we expect from a talent competition.
In the world of entertainment, where everything seems to be scripted, AGT reminds us that sometimes the most shocking and beautiful moments are the ones that happen completely by accident or defy all expectations. The 2024 season was a powerful reminder of the unpredictability and magic that comes from the raw human spirit, and we can’t wait to see what next season has in store.
AGT is more than a show—it’s a journey where the impossible becomes possible, and every moment holds the potential to change lives forever. As we close the chapter on 2024, one thing is for sure: the magic, the talent, and the shocking moments will always keep us coming back for more.